Biomaterial to build better bones with 3D printing

With both adults and children, often times bone is harvested from elsewhere in the body to replace the missing bone, which can lead to other complications and pain. Metallic implants are sometimes used, but this is not a permanent fix for growing children.

"Adults have more options when it comes to implants," said Ramille N. Shah, who led the research. "Pediatric patients do not. If you give them a permanent implant, you have to do more surgeries in the future as they grow. They might face years of difficulty."

Shah and her team aim to change the nature of bone implants, and they particularly want to help pediatric patients. Shah is an assistant professor of materials science and engineering in Northwestern's McCormick School of Engineering and of surgery in the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine.

The new study, evaluating the material with human stem cells and within animal models, was published online by the journal Science Translational Medicine. Adam E. Jakus, a postdoctoral fellow in Shah's laboratory, is the paper's first author.

Shah's 3D printed biomaterial is a mix of hydroxyapatite (a calcium mineral found naturally in human bone) and a biocompatible, biodegradable polymer that is used in many medical applications, including sutures.

Shah's hyperelastic "bone" material shows great promise in in vivo animal models; this success lies in the printed structure's unique properties. It's majority hydroxyapatite yet hyperelastic, robust and porous at the nano, micro and macro levels.

"Porosity is huge when it comes to tissue regeneration, because you want cells and blood vessels to infiltrate the scaffold," Shah said. "Our 3D structure has different levels of porosity that is advantageous for its physical and biological properties."

While hydroxyapatite has been proven to induce bone regeneration, it is also notoriously tricky to work with. Clinical products that use hydroxyapatite or other calcium phosphate ceramics are hard and brittle. To compensate for that, previous researchers created structures composed mostly of polymers, but this shields the activity of the bioceramic.

Shah's bone biomaterial, however, is 90% by weight percent hydroxyapatite and just 10% by weight percent polymer and still maintains its elasticity because of the way its structure is designed and printed. The high concentration of hydroxyapatite creates an environment that induces rapid bone regeneration.

"Cells can sense the hydroxyapatite and respond to its bioactivity," Shah said. "When you put stem cells on our scaffolds, they turn into bone cells and start to up-regulate their expression of bone specific genes. This is in the absence of any other osteo-inducing substances. It's just the interaction between the cells and the material itself."

That's not to say that other substances couldn't be combined into the ink. Because the 3D printing process is performed at room temperature, Shah's team was able to incorporate other elements, such as antibiotics, into the ink.

"We can incorporate antibiotics to reduce the possibility of infection after surgery," Shah said. "We also can combine the ink with different types of growth factors, if needed, to further enhance regeneration. It's really a multi-functional material."

One of the biggest advantages, however, is that the end product can be customised to the patient. In traditional bone transplant surgeries, the bone - after it's taken from another part of the body - has to be shaped and molded to exactly fit the area where it is needed.

Physicians would be able to scan the patient's body and 3D print a personalised product using Shah's synthetic material. Alternatively, due to its mechanical properties, the biomaterial can also be easily trimmed and cut to size and shape during a procedure. Not only is this faster, but alsoless painful compared to using autograft material.

Shah imagines that hospitals may one day have 3D printers, where they can print customised implants while the patient waits.